Loading... Please wait...

FAQ

Do I need to refrigerate my pie?

All cream pies require refrigeration.

 

Do you sell sugar free pies?
We offer Low Sugar Pies in the following flavors: Apple, Cherry, Blueberry, Chocolate, Coconut, and Banana. While you cannot order a low sugar pie online, you can place your order by phone.

 

Can I freeze my pie?
We don’t recommend it because we’re fresh baked! Nothing is better than a fresh baked pie!

 

How many pieces can I get out of my pie?
10” Large- 8 pieces
8” Medium – 6 pieces
6” Small – 2 pieces

 

Where do you bake your pies?
All of our pies are fresh baked in house at our Amherst location.

 

mjp-process-fresh-baked.jpg

 

Where does all your fruit come from?
We get our fruit fresh from all over the country! Our blackberries and raspberries are grown in Oregon and our apples, blueberries, and rhubarb come from Michigan.

 

mjp-key-lime-slice-800x600.jpgYour Key Lime Pie is not green. Why?
Because it’s baked from scratch with no added food coloring! Key Lime juice is naturally yellow, NOT green. We get our Key lime juice straight from Florida.

 

 

 

mjp-buckeye-pie-800x600.jpgWhat’s a Buckeye Pie?
Our Buckeye Cream Pie is just like the buckeye candy, only bigger and better! Light, rich, chocolate and peanut butter mousse layered to create the ultimate cream pie. Perfect for Ohio State fans or anyone who just loves peanut butter and chocolate!

 

What’s in your Peanut Butter Pie?
Peanut butter mousse whipped up light and fluffy and topped with whipped cream and peanuts.

 

What’s a Pumpkin Cheese Pie?
Our Pumpkin Pie with a layer of cream cheese right in between our flaky crust and delicious pumpkin filling.

 

What’s a Pecan Cheese Pie?
Our Pecan Pie with a layer of cream cheese that rises just under the pecans when baked.

 

Where can I buy your pies?
Our freshly baked pies are available at Heinen's, some Drug Marts, and at our Amherst location. Visit us!

 

All prices are subject to change without notice.

 

mjp-pie-graphics-web.jpg


 

Connect with us

Newsletter