Turtle Pie
Our Turtle Pie is made with a delicious light, rich, chocolate mousse and topped with whipped cream, chocolate and caramel drizzle, and pecans. A decadent treat!
Explore our top picks and seasonal specialties, baked fresh for you.
Our Turtle Pie is made with a delicious light, rich, chocolate mousse and topped with whipped cream, chocolate and caramel drizzle, and pecans. A decadent treat!
Our Blueberry Rhubarb Crumb Pie with delicious crumb topping is fresh baked daily with succulent, fresh blueberries and rhubarb to make a new all American favorite! Order one now and you won’t...
Our layered flakey pastry dough filled with our flavorful cream cheese makes this homemade strudel simply delightful. Great for breakfast! Available in two sizes.
Our French Silk Cream Pie is made with a delicious light, rich, chocolate mousse and topped with whipped cream and chocolate shavings. Calling all chocolate lovers!
This refreshing Lemon Meringue pie is one of our bestselling cream pies. Best enjoyed with our old fashioned meringue recipe! Also available with our delicious whipped cream topping.
Pecan Pie is an old fashioned favorite. We use fresh cut pecans to make this a tasty treat. Our Pecan Pie can also be ordered with a layer of cream cheese that rises just under the pecans when baked.
We love our Cherry Pie! Our sour cherry pie recipe is slightly tart, but oh so sweet! Choose from our double crust or delicious crumb topping.
Serve a little bit of Homemade Heaven with our best seller. We make our own apple pie filling using the most flavorful apples available. Our apple pie is filled with so many apples that an average...
BEST PIE
2018, 2019, 2020, 2021
Readers Choice
The Morning Journal
(Lorain, Ohio)
BEST DESSERT
2018, 2019, 2020, 2021
Readers Choice
The Morning Journal
(Lorain, Ohio)
BEST PIE
2017
Scene Magazine
Best of Cleveland
What Our Customers Are Saying
★★★★★
Extremely good pie ?. They have a full service bakery too. The selection of pies is amazing..the Key lime and peanut butter were delicious.
- Dave Zech
★★★★★
What a pleasant place to go. They not only have amazing pies butbthey carry lots of other snack foods, drinks, souvenirs and have some seating as well. Everything is very affordable too. Definitely visit this gem.
- Christian Cisneros
★★★★★
They have THE BEST carrot cake and peanut butter cookies!! I also love the atmosphere, especially during the holidays.
- Kellie McKenty
★★★★★
At this location, there is no dine in option. Carry out only. Lots of variety of candies, trail mix, cheesecakes, cream pies, fruit pies, cookies, brownies, buckeyes etc. Too many items to list. They also have chicken pot pies. Everything is homemade. They also have another store in Vermillion. Refer to website for additional information for days/times and menu.
- Cj
★★★★★
These are the most delicious pies available in Lorain County, the knock the socks off any grocery store pie. My absolute fav is the coconut cream, but my wife swears by the key lime.
- Michael Criss